Real Future Sob Stories If ObamaCare Passes
Posted by G.J. Merits in General Politics, tags: brain, canada, cancer, clinton, drug, eluting, health, healthcare, kennedy, obamacare, single payer, stent, summitUpdate: Rush Limbaugh just admitted he was wrong about stating the Republicans should not attend the summit. Republicans are knocking Obama around like a lightweight.
Watching the sob stories from the Dems in Kabuki theater is making me sick.
I come from Canada – single payer. My wife was born in Britain – public option. So a Canadian premier comes to US for heart surgery to repair a valve. In Canada he would have required a full on cracking on the sternum, in the U.S. they came in through his armpit. In Britain, a breast cancer saving drug was denied to millions on the public plan by the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE) – a real cruel acronym if ever one existed.
A drug which can give women with advanced breast cancer extra weeks or months of life has been turned down by a government watchdog body for use in the NHS.
The National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (Nice) says it proposes to reject Tyverb (lapatinib) in spite of changes in the rules brought in specifically to allow people at the end of their lives to have the chance of new and often expensive treatments.
Tyverb is the only drug licensed for women with advanced breast cancer whose tumours test positive for a protein called HER2 and for whom Herceptin, a Nice-approved drug, is no longer working. In much of the rest of Europe, Tyverb is then given, in combination with a standard chemotherapy drug called capecitabine.
Herceptin was denied until the NHS was sued.
Let’s see – Kennedy had brain cancer and he went to…hmmm….Britain? No. Germany? No. Canada? No. Mexico? No. China? No. Oh, that’s right – he stayed here in America. I wonder why?
And Bill Clinton loves American health care too:
With President Obama hoping this week’s “bipartisan summit” will move his health-care bill out of the ICU, it’s worth taking a look at a recent high-profile operation — the heart work done on former President Bill Clinton.
Clinton, of course, got the best of care — a cardiac stent (a tiny metal cylinder) coated with a drug to help keep his artery open. Recent studies in the New England Journal of Medicine and elsewhere have shown that these drug-eluting stents are more effective than bare metal ones.
But they cost two-to-four times more — and the technology is relatively new. That combination has left government-run health-care systems slow to adopt them. The disparity between the US and Canada is striking.
Per capita, our neighbors to the north receive only half as many coronary interventions. And only 30 percent of the stents placed in Canada are drug eluting, compared with a whopping 80 percent in the United States.
So a Canadian cardiac patient is less than a quarter as likely as an American to be outfitted with the kind of state-of-the-art stent that Clinton had.
In Canada, land of single-payer health insurance, you’re also less likely to get the stent as soon as the need is clear — especially in western provinces where resources are extremely limited and access is spotty. In Edmonton, Alberta, the wait for a cardiac procedure is routinely three to four months. In many areas of western Canada, less than half of angioplasties and stents are done at the same time as the original angiogram, a big waste of time and resources.
Canada has been attempting to deal with this problem of excess delay and inefficiency by introducing a database-driven system that assigns scores based on urgency. But many American cardiologists shudder at exactly this kind of solution — a federal system for deciding who needs an urgent procedure and who doesn’t. And if you were to think that rationing cardiac care is a way of saving money, you’d be dead wrong. An Austrian study just published found that the cost of waiting dramatically increases the average cost of treatment per patient.
The record of the last half-century is unmistakable: Government-dominated health sectors don’t innovate as fast, and they resist the latest discoveries because they “see” the costs up-front, and are slow to accept the benefits.
Any of the ObamaCare bills would push us in Canada’s direction, with policymakers looking hard to find overly simplistic solutions to justify lower costs for cheaper technologies. Indeed, some US “experts” are already brandishing a single 2008 study, known as the COURAGE trial, that seems to undermine the value of stents.
But ask any of the one million US patients who have received a stent over the last year if they think the capital investment that companies have made on evolving stent technology has been worth it. Perhaps even the former president would agree to the cost/benefit of stenting, even as he’s championing a form of health care that could take that routine option away.
I got sob stories for you. If ObamaCare passes, I will have millions of them. A lot more than the dems are regurgitating now.
Related:
More Vote Scoring of the GOP At Healthcare Summit
The House Goes First or ObamaCare Dies
Watch out Republicans: Obama Readies a Fallback Health-Care Proposal. Read more here.
GOP, do NOT agree to anything from this manipulative trickster. Hold your ground and review anything thoroughly. If you stick it to us on this, you will pay a dear price. They have LOST. Do not snatch defeat from the jaws of victory.
Blowhard-a-thon at Blair House: Health care summit open thread
![Real Future Sob Stories If ObamaCare Passes [del.icio.us]](http://www.thesubstratum.com/wp-content/plugins/bookmarkify/delicious.png)
![Real Future Sob Stories If ObamaCare Passes [Digg]](http://www.thesubstratum.com/wp-content/plugins/bookmarkify/digg.png)
![Real Future Sob Stories If ObamaCare Passes [Facebook]](http://www.thesubstratum.com/wp-content/plugins/bookmarkify/facebook.png)
![Real Future Sob Stories If ObamaCare Passes [Reddit]](http://www.thesubstratum.com/wp-content/plugins/bookmarkify/reddit.png)
![Real Future Sob Stories If ObamaCare Passes [StumbleUpon]](http://www.thesubstratum.com/wp-content/plugins/bookmarkify/stumbleupon.png)
![Real Future Sob Stories If ObamaCare Passes [Twitter]](http://www.thesubstratum.com/wp-content/plugins/bookmarkify/twitter.png)
![Real Future Sob Stories If ObamaCare Passes [Email]](http://www.thesubstratum.com/wp-content/plugins/bookmarkify/email.png)




Entries (RSS)